- Skie's/Rob's Voice: The Game: Based on Rob singing the DDR songs "Bumble Bee" and "Cotton Eye Joe" with different lyrics.
- Ferret Sex: The Flash Game (Episode 62)
- Laser Cats
- Loki's World of Randomness
- RicePrincess presents Boobies and Pandas: Brought up during a talk about immature 8-bit hacks.
- Forbidden Bomberman: Skie's idea on how to make Bomberman more interesting.
- Pen & Paper: Based on the DS game LOL, the gameplay of which could be easily be done by using pen and paper.
- Furries: Would be rated D for Drama.
- Cosplayers vs. Furries: A fighting game featuring two big dramas.
- WhatTheyPlay.com Snap: A Nintendo Wii game involving taking pictures of two guys kissing a disembodied head while on top of a couple having sex shouting "fuck".
- Crazy SUV Cellphone driver
- Blow Shit Up
- Puzzle Sluts: Better than Bubble Bath Babes. A knockoff of Puzzle Fighter, and would include an alternate version, Male Puzzle Sluts.
- Puzzle Sluts II X : For Matching Service: The sequel with an updated roster, now including Turians!
- Everything Is A Trap: It's a trap.
- Bungee Ferret Tossing: The first OLR Dream Game to become a reality. Available now as of 9/17/2012!
- Megaman 10rgy: 80 Robot Masters, 1 Robot Mistress. The final boss will be Gutsman's Ass.
- Golden Girls: The Video Game
- GWAR vs. Kidz Bop
- Cooch Stars: comes in 'Lady Gaga' and 'Beyonce' editions where you shoot stars from out of their... yknow.
- Fart Monsters: Like Pokemon, but with more farting...
- Topless Chicks Shooting: Most likely an all-nude sequel to Parodius/Otomedius (or the companion game, No-Pants Sword Fight)
- RuPaul's Drag Race: The Game: Fighting drag queens! Also costarring the fat sassy black woman, Ruy Paul!
- Silent Dog: A new Silent Hill game, starring the dog from the Dog Ending of Silent Hill 2.
- Playstation All-sores: Gonorrhea vs Syphllis? Only on Playstation!
- President Cat PONG: Inspired by Listless from Episode 463, AVAILABLE NOW! Grab it here
- Animal Crossing: After Dark: It's animal crossing... but rated M for mature!
- GLAMSTERS: Hampsters with tiaras, crowns, etc.
- Downton Abbey Wrestling: Victorian-era Smackdown!
- OLR Gauntlet: Basically a remake of the arcade classic (and Classic Game of the Week) Gauntlet, but with Pinkberry instead of bags of food, and possibly LOKI as Tingle as the Elf!
- Pixel Shits: Now officially the second OLR Dream Game to become a real thing, once again courtesy of yyr! Play it here! (Also available now on Steam, and be sure to check out the official sequel, Pixel Poops Number 2 available now for the NES courtesy of LOKI! You can check out a five level demo of PP #2 by going here and grab the full version of the game on Steam here)
- Fantasia Final: Busqueda Mistica! (Final Fantasy: Mexican Quest): Featuring Mexican Luchadores instead of Dragoons, and Mariachi instead of Spoony Bards!
- PBS Fighters - From Episode #647, Basically a fighting game featuring characters from programs that appeared on PBS (Sesame Street, Square One/Mathnet, Fawlty Towers, Doctor Who)
- Literally No Man's Sky - From Episode #653, it's the sequel to No Man's Sky, but everything is destroyed! (Literally!)
- Cube: The Videogame - Based on the cult-classic horror movie, can YOU escape the cube?!
- Untitled Smoosh Game - Similar to Untitled Goose Game, but you play as Mr. Smoosh and have to interrupt the podcast as much as you can!
- CaTTaxi / BMX Triple Cat - Ride your bike and deliver cats to their happy new home!
- Corgi Gambling - With different kinds of Corgis instead of chips
From Episode 158, in response to the Ask Orange Lounge question What would your ultimate video game be?
- Skie - Golfland Birthday Party Sniper
- Darksakura - Guardian Legend: The MMORPG
- Xtofer - In the Ass
- LOKI - Console Wars (fighting game with every character from all systems)
PATENT PENDING